TWEAKING THINKERS . . . !

" New Age Fallacy - When You Cannot Do Anything Good, Claim Whatever You Do Is The Best !" . . . . . np

An Out Of Favour Durbari



Now there are some people who never fail to astonish me. Not necessarily in nice way always.

Other than being a Sonia Gandhi hater, Tavleen Singh’s other full time occupation is that of being a journalist. She used to be a field reporter earlier and now is a columnist.     
Tavleen Singh
Sometime earlier she was caught, with her dog crapping on the streets of Mumbai by an Municipal official. On being reprimanded she said made excuses like there wasn’t any signage asking not to litter & there weren’t any dustbins around.

(Here is the link : http://www.dnaindia.com/mumbai/report-columnist-in-a-soup-over-dog-poo-1072824)

Recently, in one of her many sermons to the world she tweeted about how Delhi citizens need to keep the city cleaner. When reminded of her earlier behaviour she retorted saying, ‘Next time my dog needs a crap, I will get her to your doorstep.’


Extremely witty! 










More about her below:


Her father was a high ranking army official residing in Lutyens and friends with the great Khushwant Singh. She got her first job in Mr Singh’s publication. This in anyone else’s case would be nepotism. But not for Tavleen.

She also recently wrote a column stating that Bharat is not Swachh as Dalits have been employed in this job and are inefficient.

Reading her columns one might believe that Tavleen Singh has a strong dislike for political dynasties. But her keeping mum on her best friends like Naveen Patnaik & Vasundhara Raje raises doubts.

Her dislike for Muslims is well known. What’s not known that the father of her only son (a author in his own right) is a late governor of Pakistan.

Lavasa has been under a lot of controversy for various reasons but Singh has always chosen to defend it through her columns. It may be interesting to note that she has been living in with Gulabchand, chief developer of Lavasa for 25 years. These columns have been carried without any disclosure. Her then editor Shekhar Gupta at Indian Express too needs to share the blame of keeping the readers in the dark.

I don’t generally like to comment on anyone’s personal life. But for someone who is elitist & self righteous in her columns all the time, needs to sometime be shown her hypocritical self.

And lastly about her dislike for Sonia Gandhi. We are all aware of how much the family since Indira Gandhi’s time loves its coterie. It is amusing to know that Tavleen Singh herself was part of Sonia Gandhi’s coterie for a long time in the 80’s. For some reason they fell out & since then Tavleen Singh has termed the coterie a Durbar.


Tavleen Singh is nothing but a bitter, out of favour, durbari.



On an funny note to end some one has opened a parody account as Tavleen Singh’s Dog. You can follow it here, https://twitter.com/TavleensDog

Being Mahatma . . .

I have always sensed that generally speaking, a lot of BJP & RSS supporters if not all have an inherent dislike for Mahatma Gandhi. It is not just an ancedotal account but one comes across articles, books, political speeches which give away not just the disagreement but the dislike. It is deeply entrenched in their minds and like all deep hatreds, it is difficult to even get a point across. I have umpteen number of times heard statements like ‘He was the father of the nation, but that nation was Pakistan!’ He has been accused of being a calculative ‘bania’ (references to caste as a behavioural pattern is another characteristic trait of this group) who prolonged India’s freedom struggle to gain more prominence. He has also been blamed for not giving India its best Prime Minister referring to another Congress stalwart Sardar Vallabhai Patel and instead gave them, according to the Gandhi haters, an inept Jawaharlal Nehru. And that’s the reason we suffer from economic backwardness, weak foreign policy and dynastic politics. (Nehru himself wouldn’t have allowed it but their dislike for Nehru is a huge chapter by itself) They blame him for most of the ills that are holding the country back.

Many of them even celebrate the ideology of Nathuram Godse, if not his act. I have been witness to some, albeit fewer even justifying the act! More famously Bal Thackeray did it! So one would presume that when it came to bestow a title upon their beloved leaders, Gandhi would not be in the reckoning of any comparison. But in fact, what happens in reality is exactly the opposite.

So why the fascination with Gandhi?
This group has actually not had an icon in India’s modern history with a national presence and appeal that transcends generations. Like say a Gandhi, a Nehru, a Patel or an Ambedkar did. One of course cannot discount the great leaders like Shyama Prasad Mukherjee, Deendayal Upadhyaya, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, L K Advani. Reasons for this are many. Some of which can be cited as follows- firstly the limited contribution of leaders from this group during a nationally integrating movement like the freedom struggle. Secondly, the non inclusive, sectarian Hindutva outlook in a country which has been a home to people of various faiths, cultures for hundreds of years and has been largely secular during most of its pre & post independent existence. And lastly due to the bend towards the right in a country which has been socialist for most of its part with a huge underprivileged population.Hence, the comparison with stalwarts of the past who were far removed from this group’s ideology.

What has been happening recently is really curious. Anil Ambani & Kiran Bedi have termed Mr. Modi a Mahatma. Now like most of the other corporate honchos, Mr Ambani is enamoured by Mr Modi for his business friendly policies. He had said it nearly three years ago before many even thought of Mr. Modi’s possibility of coming to the centre. But as things stand today, he probably knew something that many obviously did not. The influence of ‘Sea-Wind’ (Original Ambani Residence) on major political appointments has always been a matter of great speculation. His reasons are strictly business. On the other hand, Kiran Bedi’s hero-worship is a more recent one. After fighting for Lokpal at the centre, she went public with her earlier tactical and later a more blatant support to the CM who didn’t even have a Lokayukta for the longest time in Gujarat. But she is known to forgive those who seek transformation even if they may have been on the wrong side of the law. Case in point being her applaudable stint in Tihar jail. To be fair, Mr. Modi has not been indicted in any wrong doing of any kind. But still the comparison is far-fetched to say the least.

Recently, Arun Jaitley likened Ramdev Baba to Mahatma Gandhi. Now not many can challenge his yoga abilities, but this comparison again is unfair. One understands Mr. Jaitley’s compulsion to thank one of his star campaigners but ‘Mahatma’? Seriously? Just like Gandhi, Baba Ramdev too decided to take on the might of the establishment for justice. But when police decided to arrest him unlike Gandhi who always courted arrest lawfully, Ramdev wore female clothes and fled from his ‘satyagraha’. And the British (who saw him as the biggest thorn in their flesh) did not accuse Gandhi of any financial offence. Unlike Ramdev Baba, Gandhi displayed immense physical and moral courage.

Coming back to the question ”When there is such an inherent dislike for the man amongst your supporters then why compare your ‘hero’ to such a man?” Why not claim your heroes to be the reincarnation of someone like Guru Golwalkar? And if you want to compare your heroes to someone like Gandhi then your supporters can’t be dismissing his immense contribution.

We understand the people who for sycophantic (one thought sycophancy would bow out with ousted Congress) reasons compare Modi & Baba Ramdev with Gandhi, have little respect for the father of the nation(India) but why hurt others who do. You cannot represent a group that shares Nathuram Godse’s ideology and still goes around bestowing ‘Gandhi’ as a title. That is a serious disparity.


In his chronicling of Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi’s life, historian Ramachandra Guha in the biography titled ‘Gandhi before India’ lets us in on a fact that not many are aware of. He tells us that a Gujarati businessman and a close friend of Gandhi, Pranjivan Mehta was the first one to refer to him as ‘Mahatma’. In terming someone as a ‘great soul’ the aforementioned people probably want to claim their own place in history. History proved Mehta right, but we need more proof from the present to bestow that title on anyone else.

Re-Shuffled or Re-Suffered . . . !

Hello! A very Happy New Year to all my readers and their loved ones! Due to my last post, I was issued death threats by Dawood Ibrahim and a 'Fatwa' from Lashkar-e-Pakistan-e-Taliban-e-Mohajir! So I went underground. Even now I am writing this post from a 'secure' and 'undisclosed location' (readers, kindly don't compound my problems by requesting my exact location) But, I owe it to my beloved readers so here I am risking everything and posting what I have to SAY about the latest Cabinet Shuffle at the Centre.
Since last five months, the Prime Minister has been sending out feelers about this major Re-shuffle in his Cabinet. Scam after scam this government has been found wanting, when confronted for action. The response had been first a denial and then a timid step in name of action against corruption or plain incompetence! Hence, a lot rode on this 'Re-shuffle' but what it turned out to be can be summed up in a Hindi proverb - " खोदा पहाड़ और निकला चूहा, और वो भी मरा हुआ" ! Lets see how UPA has dug this hill! (and their heal in denying the nation the response it deserves)
  • Maximum goodies in terms of elevation to Cabinet Ministries or better ministries have been doled out to Uttar Pradesh, Kerala and West Bengal. It is only incidental that they go to polls the coming months.
  • There was a hype being created by the Congress party about possible induction of youth. Being the oldest party in the country, their parameter for young starts at the age of 47.
  • Some of the re-shuffle has been baffling. Vilasrao Deshmukh who was running Heavy Industries and Public Enterprise has been now moved to Rural Development. Industries as well as rural economy both are in shambles in Maharashtra where, he has been the Chief Minister twice.
  • Heavy Industries and Public Enterprise has been given to NCP's Prafful Patel who previously headed Aviation and saw to it that Air India nosedived for a crash landing from which it may never recover. After helping the 'Kingfishers' & 'Indigoons' to fly their 'Jet' at cost of the National carrier he might now look to wipe out all other 'ailing' PSU's, thus helping some 'Adaani' (in Marathi it means illiterate)
  • Murli Deora was busy overlooking the fight between two brothers warring over the Petroleum 'ratnas' during his tenure as Oil and Petroleum ministry rather than controlling fuel prices. Probably, his proximity to the corporate world saw him being demoted to Corporate Affairs. (oops!)
  • Sharad Pawar had been saying reduce his burden and so the government took away consumer affairs and has given him food supply. Perfect! For minister who has done nothing to address the issue of Farmer suicide or HUGE prise rise, Food supply is perfect choice. He will make sure there are 10 more Lavasa's, 3 IPL's per year and 100 Lalit Modis. For price rise he has been saying they will come down in 4 days since last 2 years!
  • C.P. Joshi - From Rural Development to Roads & Transport. From welfare to infrastructure! If you can figure that out let me know.
  • Jaipal Reddy who headed Urban Development has been given Oil and Petroleum! CWG village was such a huge miracle (I hope you get the sarcasm) and God knows Oil ministry needs a miracle.
  • Dow chemicals unofficial advocate Kamal Nath has been put in charge of Urban Development from Roads and Transport. He had promised some few Lakhs of kilometers by end of his term, which was never going to happen so now he has an excuse.
  • One of the Oldest ministers his the Cabinet, Mr. M.S. Gill who was in charge of Youth and Sports ministry has been given Statistics, Science and Technology. He has been haded over Statistics probably to keep a account of corruption during the CWG and Science to come with a Vaccine against the disease of corruption called ' Kalmadise'

Such and many more bizarre changes carried out with no pattern or trend. Rahul Gandhi cannot even blame collation politics this time around (golden excuse). Seems to me it was more of a Congress appeasement programme than Cabinet Reshuffle. (I believe the Andhra effect) 37 changes, and Not a single, not even one minister accused of mis-appropriation or under-performance has been reprimanded. In fact not a single minister has been dropped. All they have done is shuffled the cards around. We seem to be in a tricky high table game of cards, where cards drawn for us (read minsters) are really bad! So the Prime Minister and Sonia Gandhi (the inner voice wala version) should have understood as much as you would re-shuffle them its no point. Positions have been changed People have not!

The scariest part of this is the Prime Minister said that this was a 'minor' re-shuffle (remember 37 changes) and there would be a major one after the budget! Phew! ( you guys need not worry I wont write about that one) In short, the nation is going to Re-Suffer due to this Re-Shuffle!

Till then take care and spread the cheer ! . . . . . nP.

NA-PAKistan Cricket !

Pakistan Cricket is under dark clouds! I might as well add, again! And as usual I have something to SAY about it. But, for a change I will spare you the conspiracy theories! (Actually, I do not have any) And neither do I have any major scoops! (except, there are many more fixers in the closet) All I have is completely stupid and unnecessary take on it! (I am so predictable)
But I feel like doing this post like the science answer, to a question which asked us to enlist the salient features of a particular topic. So like wise, here I go,
  • Pakistan Cricket Board is the only sporting body which might make us feel, Suresh Kalmadi is not such bad guy. If that is an overstatement, at least it makes us feel that BCCI is not the biggest fool. (But, they are close second)
  • Not just the sporting body, many Indian Cricket fans would be grateful to the Almighty for players like even Ravinder Jadeja rather than Salman Butt or Mohammad Asif. (We prefer you being paid only once for under-performance)
  • Many Indians are happy that it is not happening to us and many people are more happy that it is happening to the Pakistanis. (Theory is if Pakistan Cricket is isolated it will save our nation from mourning during a loss to them)
  • Indian media is sad, they were not able to break the story! (just imagine the TRPs!)
  • We have to be happy that even are politicians are smarter than theirs! After a scam, Pakistani politicians have jumped the gun, unlike their Indian counterparts who would have dragged the issue for so long that everyone would have lost interest. (And our politicians give better excuses as well)
  • Excuses remind me, a Pakistani news papers claims that it is R&AW (Indian counter intelligence agency) which has framed these young cricketers! Now, isn't that a clear over-estimation of what the lethargic agency can do! (But, I am sure R&AW would more than eager to claim the credit for it)
  • Not just the sensational media, even Pakistan High Commissioner to United Kingdom has blamed it completely on India. From, lack of law and order in that country to a economy in dire state to terrorism to now match fixing, everything is India's fault. I am dreading the day they blame India for inflicting the pain of having Zardari as their President. (Indian policy makers would never do anything against Pakistan, they are busy messing up their own country)
  • A corrective theory to counter this menace being put forth is, betting should be legalised. The logic is if you cannot stop it, it would be better to earn taxes from it. Next in line for the demand of legalisation are match fixing, loot, extortion. (Logic is the same as the previous one)
  • And finally the most funniest part, President of Pakistan, Asif Ali Zardari said he will punish these corrupt players. I say funny because he in his country has caught on the name Mr. 10% for his corrupt ways. (Javed Miandad who's son is married to Dawood Ibrahim's daughter has also said he is ready to help Pakistan cricket)
  • To sum it up, Pakistani cricket was in already a Fix, it needy some heavy duty Fixing but instead the players have indulged in Match Fixing! (sad no? I know!)

Till then be happy and spread the cheer ! . . . . . nP

GO 'VAIN' DA RE GOPALA!

As the title suggests , the stupid theory that I am throwing at you'll this time, is related to the ' Dahi-Handi ' festival. At the outset let me clear that I am as depressing as one can get but, I love all the festivals irrespective of their origin and I am all for it to be celebrated with utmost zeal. (Why do I clarify so much? The reason is that I want to sound very intelligent but I do not have the guts to stand by what I say)
Each passing year one gets to see these huge hoardings, each one claiming their 'Dahi-Handi Ustsav' being the biggest in terms of the participation, height, prize money, crowd turn up, media coverage etc. The event is conducted with great flair. With a public holiday being declared in the state, there is huge turnout. Celebrities turn up at different locations throughout the day. There is huge media conclave at major mandals claiming exclusive rights to coverage. (And mind you National Media) And every local cable operator telecasts it the whole day on local channel. And corporates aren't far behind. From pan-masala to energy drinks to even the supposedly niche investment banking firms, all want their share of the visibility. And unmistakeably if there is so much visibility how could politicians stay behind. In fact, even if these 'events' are conducted by youth centric NGOs, their parent organisational head is always a major local politician. But, what is it that is bothering me? (let us just say the sadist in me) Can I not tolerate the middle class boys and girls having fun for a day? That too when it is a festival with religious, traditional and cultural significance! But, one just has too look at the prize money involved in these events (PR exercise for everyone involved) and all the tall claims of it being having to do anything with religion or culture would crumble like an old chawl in Mumbai crumbles during monsoon. The money we are talking here is huge to say the least. The highest amount this year being, Rs.77,77,777. (I still do not have the new rupee symbol) Others are not far behind, with likes of 50 lakhs, 31 lakhs, 25 lakhs etc.
My issue lies with the kind of celebration. Earlier, there used to be a small mandal organising a celebration early in the morning, with the funds coming from residents living around. Slowly, these mandals got politicised and wanted to attract political mileage. Local shop-owners and businessman were forced into giving 'chanda' as it is known. Both parties kept the transactions unaccounted as both had many things to hide. And now the practice has nearly got a face of an established syndicate with major corporates jumping into the fray and for the media too, Dahi Handi coming in Handy. No one seems to be interested in, how much money comes in, how the money comes in. Where does it go? Does it all go?It would be extremely naive and even foolish to an extent to think that with a politician at the helm one would have a clean, corruption free event. Many of us would still turn our backs on this part saying chalta hai ! (we should change 'सत्यमेव जयते' to 'चलता है' in our National Emblem) But, what about the risk that this event puts the lives of these young men. Higher the prize money, higher the risk! (just for confirmation check the next day's newspapers) One would say participants are aware but one cannot absolve the organisers of the responsibility as they increase the stakes. We face water cuts in the city, many parts of our country are under drought, but during these utsavs water tankers are available in abundance, just to add to the 'festive' mood. Such blatant and shameless use of a scarce resource is criminal to say the least. And if this doesn't anger you enough, even Fire-Brigade is used for the same purposes. I am not even getting into noise pollution caused and security challenges posed during such large scale events.
I have written the post presuming readers know that Dahi Handi is celebrated on the day next to जन्मास्थिमी i.e. the birth of Lord Krishna. But, I think someone needs to remind us why Lord Krishna used to play his Dahi Handi. Even during his time the social ratio was a skewed one. His poor friends who actually produced the makhan never even got a wiff of it. So as to give them the taste of the 'creamy layer' (in the most literal sense) He, would indulge in this sport. (I hope Lord Krishna's methods would not be judged as communist or socialist) If we have to fake that we are celebrating this festival in the manner we are, for religious reasons, we might as well do it the way Shri Krishna did it, for the needy. In the prize money of the biggest Handi alone, as many as 800 children would be able to complete their entire education.

It could be for any worthy cause, and I am sure the participating Gopalas would still be enthusiastic about it as prize is not the major criteria for them. (Anyway there are enough reports of prize money not reaching them) In this way we would have Govinda in the purest form and the whole exercise would not ' GO in VAIN '.(I am grinning broadly as I think I am just brilliant with words) Govinda re Gopala!
Till then be happy and spread the cheer! . . . . . np